Edited George FitzGerald (April 23, 2015 01:03:00 AM)
Originally posted by A.J. Reimann:
I am a brand new l1 and first time posting. I feel as we are still in the ap end step and turn has not past, issue the nap a warning and back the game up to right before nap cast the spell. This would be less detrimental then the ap loosing the four life which could have big implications latter in the game. . If the turn had past you would leave it and issue both a warning for gpe grv.
Please let me know if I am off on this and thank you in advance.
Edited Thiago Perígolo Souza (April 23, 2015 05:39:38 AM)
EXAMPLESNilva used R and convoke with 3 white creatures to pay for a 2RR spell, which is not a legal option. The spell has been cast with improper mana.
A. A player casts Wrath of God for 3W (actual cost 2WW).
A player allows another player in the game to commit a Game Play Error, and does not point it out immediately.Arridor caught the error quickly, but as evidenced by him adjusting life totals and allowing the spell to finish resolving he did not catch it immediately. I am inclined to apply a FtMGS here, but I would not be surprised if a more experienced judge told me that this was immediate enough to not assess this penalty. I would appreciate hearing more on this since the rest of the case seems clear cut.
Edited Matthew At Lee (April 23, 2015 01:52:57 PM)
Edited Andrew Keeler (April 23, 2015 11:10:08 PM)
Edited Patrick Vorbroker (April 29, 2015 03:08:04 PM)
You must be registered in order to post to this forum.