(players can get a second bye when all other players on the same points have also already had a bye)
Clarification: Players can only get a bye twice in a tournament under very specific circumstances, which include (but are not limited to) the following:
- In an event which includes drafts, a player can receive a bye within each draft done, as well as once outside the draft rounds of the format. (think limited GPs and 7-man draft pods in Day 2)
- A player who in a bracketed tournament may receive (effectively) a second bye if the match which determines his opponent ends in a double match loss or double-DQ.
- It is theoretically possible for a player in a 2000+-player Grand Prix (or other tournament with a non-top-8 cut) tournament to receive a bye in both Day 1 and Day 2.
- WER randomly decides that a person should get a second bye. (which I have seen…)
The bye is awarded randomly to a player who has not yet received a bye, and is among the lowest point total of players for which at least one player in that point total has not yet received a bye. (to sanity-check this, as the full WotC implementation of Swiss pairings is not public, I did double-check that both DCIR and WER follow this rule)