Edited John Eriksson (Dec. 18, 2015 04:57:15 AM)
Originally posted by IPG:
If a player forgot to draw cards, discard cards, or return cards from their hand to another zone, that player does so.
Edited Jessica Livingston (Dec. 19, 2015 01:37:26 PM)
Originally posted by IPG:Also, backing up through a draw and some deck manipulation is pretty worrisome, especially in legacy, where there's likely to be a shuffle effect available (though it might not necessarily be available).
If a player forgot to draw cards, discard cards, or return cards from their hand to another zone, that player does so.
Originally posted by IPG:
Players are considered to have looked at a card when they have been able to observe the face of a hidden card, or when a card is moved any significant amount from a deck, but before it touches the other cards in their hand
Originally posted by IPG:. That is, if we fix this with a backup, we'll put a random card from hand on top of deck, not shuffle, re-tap the appropriate permanents, and then we'll be in a state where Anton can finish resolving brainstorm correctly. (where he'll place back 2 cards, untap, draw one of them, and continue on)
If the identity of a card involved in reversing an action is unknown to one of the players (usually because it was drawn), a random card is chosen from the possible candidates
Edited Talin Salway (Dec. 19, 2015 03:40:41 AM)
Originally posted by Robert Langmaid:
Talin Salway: how would they have an extra card by putting only one back. The drew 3 for the brainstorm and we're suppose to put 2 back. Then they drew 1 of those 2 for their turn. Thus if we put one back it is the same as if they resolved correctly then drew for their turn.
Originally posted by Lyle Waldman:
I think this is just GRV.
Originally posted by Lyle Waldman:
I think this is just GRV. As much as this looks very much like DEC, it doesn't actually fit any of the rules for DEC in IPG. I think we can rewind through this, so I would:
1) Return a card at random from Anton's hand to the top of his deck (his draw for turn).
2) Tap Anton's permanents (the ones he had tapped during Nicolas' end step).
3) Ask Anton to put 2 cards from his hand on top of his library.
If a player forgot to draw cards, discard cards, or return cards from their hand to another zone, that player does so.
Originally posted by Marc Shotter:Lyle Waldman
I think this is just GRV.
I'm curious why you wouldn't apply the GRV default fix and are working through a backup?
Edited Lyle Waldman (Dec. 21, 2015 09:42:08 PM)
You must be registered in order to post to this forum.