Originally posted by Joseph Wiesenberg:I can't find anything in this situation to support reasoning for DEC also. Let's take a look at the definition:
1) The IPG has language about an infraction not being DEC if it occurred as a result of/immediately after a prior GRV, and Andrew skipping several priority passes to resolve his bident trigger sounds like a GRV to me.
IPG 2.3Andrew put a card in his hand due to Bident of Thassa ability, so it was not illegal in this way. It was also not a result of resolving objects on stack in an incorrect order.
A player illegally puts one or more cards into his or her hand and, at the moment before he or she began the instruction or action that put a card into his or her hand, no other Game Play Error or Communication Policy Violation had been committed, and the error was not the result of resolving objects on the stack in an incorrect order. If the player received confirmation from his or her opponent before drawing the card (including confirming the number of cards when greater than one), the infraction is not Drawing Extra Cards. Additionally, it is Drawing Extra Cards if a player has excess cards in their hand that he or she cannot account for.
Edited Piotr Łopaciuk (Oct. 10, 2013 02:54:54 PM)
Originally posted by Riki Hayashi:Easy: “Correct me if I'm wrong: you have 35 2/2 tokens and 3 life.” :)
I cannot think of a scenario where not saying something should lead to a CPV.
Originally posted by Eric Crump:
In that case, it is the nonactive player's responsibility to say “stop on your upkeep.”
Originally posted by Nathaniel Lawrence:
Your position then is that we do nothing in this case, because NAP didn't speak up fast enough?
Originally posted by Adam Zakreski:
However, from the scenario as described, Andrew has just finished declaring attackers and has drawn a card.
Originally posted by Eric Crump:Nathaniel Lawrence
Your position then is that we do nothing in this case, because NAP didn't speak up fast enough?
I usually tell my opponent, “Pass turn, stop on your upkeep.” In the instance of the OP, the active player just slammed down a creature sideways giving Norbert no opportunity to act.
Edited Rebecca Lawrence (Oct. 11, 2013 03:13:58 AM)
You must be registered in order to post to this forum.