Edited Jacopo Strati (Nov. 6, 2017 03:04:11 AM)
Originally posted by Scott Marshall:
O'fficial confirmation: Emilien is correct. Other than a few specific things - number and type of counter, e.g. - that are listed in the Player Communication Policy as Free information, counting things is usually Derived.
“How many spells have you cast?” –> Derived, don't have to answer;
“Did you cast A, B, C, and D this turn?” –> Free, you have to answer (but if they forgot about E, you don't have to volunteer that info).
d:^D
Originally posted by Jake Eakle:If I were playing, I would answer that with “figure it out”, and I'd be very disappointed in a judge that rules that I have to answer more precisely.
How about “What was the first spell you cast this turn?”
Edited Joaquín Pérez (Nov. 6, 2017 03:18:10 PM)
Originally posted by Francesco Scialpi:Please, don't try to angle shoot. Our policies aren't comprehensive, you will always be able to push them more and more into corner cases that will become harder and harder to get a definitive answer, and will more and more devolve into “it depends”.
A bit of angle-shooting:
Originally posted by Francesco Scialpi:
Is AP obliged to correct NAP and tell something like ”Only one, the copy isn't cast"?
You must be registered in order to post to this forum.