Infraction for Nathan - Improper drawing at start of game. If he has 6 in hand already we remove one at random, shuffle his deck and he may continue to mulligan as normal. Angus has not had a chance to stop the situation, as such Angus gets no penalty.

Thank you everyone for participating in this week's scenario. All of you detected Nathan's infraction correctly, Game Play Error - Improper Drawing at the Begining of Game. The penalty is pretty clear, Warning and the only area where there have been some discussions is on how to apply the fix.

Nathan must decide to keep or continue taking mulligans with a hand of 5 cards. Asking him to draw 6 and remove 1 card at random is completely correct as per IPG. However, if we ask him to draw a hand of 5 cards we are executing a shortcut for that procedure, not a deviation.

See you in next scenario!