Hello,

with reference to Mox Amber, my understanding is that “The word ”legendary“ in ”legendary creatures and planeswalkers“ refers to both creatures and planeswalkers”", as reported here:

http://www.cranialinsertion.com/article/2657

So should a player somehow control, say, a white non-legendary planeswalker, they couldn't get white mana from Mox Amber.

However, the card is worded differently in Italian, i.e. “Aggiungi un mana di un qualsiasi colore tra quelli dei planeswalker e delle creature leggendarie che controlli.”, and seems referring explicitly to “planeswalkers and legendary creatures”.

Which version is correct?

Hi,

The English Oracle text is correct. You either need to control a legendary planeswalker or a legendary creature for the Mox to count it. It will not count a nonlegendary planeswalker (like a token planeswalker made by Jace, Cunning Castaway). It's a known issue in a few languages and will be look at to be clarified in the future.

Thanks,
Nathan Long