Hello judges
A player asked me that "Can I cast
Force of will with pitch cost from graveyard when I have
Wrenn and Six's emblem?“
I answered to ”yes. that is not Alternative Cost. so you can choice pitch cost.“
A player asked ”OK If same situation,I can play
Daze with pitch cost right?“
I said to ”Of course“
A player asked to ”Can I discard to land card of returned by pitch cost for cost of Retrace if I don't have land in my hand?“
I know player can pay cost in any order, so I answered to ”Yes" at that time.
After that I talked to other judge for that situation.
We agreed to that a player can't play Daze at that situation.
Because player don't have enough resource before start to pay cost.
However if that is true ,that is strange situation.
I think if player have a land card in his hand, it is legal action that return land card and discard to that card.
But, can other people know that a player have other land in hand?
If a player return and discard that card, opponent can't know a player has other land in hand or not.
How does a player prove to have other land in his hand if a player want to discard to returned card?
Does A player have to separate return card and hand like
Sylvan Library and have to discard to land in his hand?
But a player should be able to discard to returned card.
Or a player have to show land card in his hand?
It is no problem action but strange move at tournament scene.
It is not thought experiment and will be happen to legacy tournament.
Please tell me answer.
Thanks.