Please keep the forum protocol in mind when posting.

Rules Q&A » Post: Ruling On Blood Scrivener and Read the Bones

Ruling On Blood Scrivener and Read the Bones

Oct. 3, 2013 09:58:58 AM

Anthony Abby Swyryt
Judge (Uncertified)

USA - Northeast

Ruling On Blood Scrivener and Read the Bones

Hello All, First post.

Last night one of the players in my LGS had a very unique situation, I made the Flash ruling, but I feel I need to confirm both the ruling and my understanding of why.

The Scenario:

Player A controls A blood Scrivener with one card in hand. He casts his only card, Read the bones. How many cards does he draw/life does he lose?

My Ruling as i explained it.

“When you cast the card it moves zones. So if there are no other cards in your hand with a spell on the stack, you are hellbent. Magic handles all instances of draw x cards as if it was draw 1 card x times, so you would scry 2, then draw a card twice. With that logic, blood scrivener would trigger on the first draw replacing the draw 1 card with 2, then you qould draw the second card. Essentially, you would scry 2, draw 3 cards and loose 3 life.”

When asked about muliples Scriveners, I just said it extrapolates, So 2 would be Scry 2 draw 4 loose 4, etc etc.“

My questions are:

1. Was my ruling correct?
2. Was the reasoning behind my ruling correct”
3. Would that explaination be suitable to deliver to a player without it being considered “advice”.

Thanks,

Tony

Edited Anthony Abby Swyryt (Oct. 3, 2013 04:40:35 PM)

Oct. 3, 2013 10:22:54 AM

Jason Lemahieu
Judge (Level 3 (Judge Academy)), Tournament Organizer

USA - Great Lakes

Ruling On Blood Scrivener and Read the Bones

While we await one of the official Forum Moderators to come and answer your question, I'll supply this hopefully helpful reading material from the Rules Tip Blog:

http://blogs.magicjudges.org/rulestips/2013/04/blood-scrivener-and-draw-two-cards-effects-2/

Oct. 30, 2013 01:37:18 AM

Daniel Kitachewsky
Judge (Uncertified)

France

Ruling On Blood Scrivener and Read the Bones

The rules tip is correct.

Card draws always happen one at a time (draw 2 cards is equivalent to draw 1 card, then draw 1 card). When you replace a string of card draws, replacement effects can treat the first card draw differently from the others.

Daniel Kitachewsky
L3, Paris, France
Rules NetRep