Originally posted by Jorge Monteiro:
In a casual game, a player using his “banned dredge” deck reanimated a Golgari Grave-Troll with no other creature in the graveyard. How many counters does he get and why?
The Troll has a static ability that replaces how it enters the battlefield. This replacement effect is applied to the event before the modified event happens, so the Troll is still in the graveyard when the replacement effect is applied. It sees one creature card in the player's graveyard, so the Troll will enter the battlefield with one counter.