I would just like to clarify a couple things with 614.12:
Let's say there is a resolved
Hallowed Moonlight effect, and I am resolving a
Sun Titan's trigger.
1. If I currently have 4 devotion to blue and target
Thassa, God of the Sea, does she enter or is she exiled?
2. If I control a
Starfield of Nyx and I target some enchantment which would
be my fifth enchantment, does it enter or is it exiled?
I feel that these are effectively the same situation, but present them separately just for clarity.
The disconnect that I have seen others struggle with (and, to be sure, I don't entirely understand it myself) is that this wording
Originally posted by 614.12:
Check the characteristics of the permanent as it would exist on the battlefield, taking into account continuous effects that already exist and would apply to the permanent
would suggest to many that, for example,
Sulfur Falls entering the battlefield with
Prismatic Omen (and no other lands) in play would enter untapped. The continuous effect of Omen already exists, and it would apply to the Falls. However,
Callum's post here is counter to that.
The purpose here is twofold: first, to prompt an answer for Thassa entering on a board with 4 blue devotion (because, surely, people will want an answer from post rule change); and second, to hopefully gain the tools to adequately explain to others
why this is the case.
Edited Andrew Villarrubia (Oct. 12, 2017 02:24:17 PM)